Things Should Be Judged by Merit

A picture hung in a public hall,
And it was much admired by all,
Painted by a true artist’s hand,
The subject it was truly grand.

Its fame o’er the whole world resounds,
Valued at ten thousand pounds,
Beauteous lady none ’ere passed her,
She was the work of an old master.

At last a critic keen did gaze
And saw ’twas work of modern days,
Then quick it was pronounced a daub,
And artist but a money grab.

The true, the noble and the grand,
Will lend to struggling helping hand,
Then let no man of dues be shorn,
If he a subject doth adorn.

Where this text comes from

First published in Poems of James McIntyre (1889). First located printing is this volume; an earlier periodical printing has not been established. [1]

Structure read from the source's markup; the words have not been compared against a page scan. Last checked 2026-08-20.

Taken from Standard Ebooks, standardebooks/james-mcintyre_poetry, poetry.xhtml. Rights: public domain (SE dedication; underlying text pre-1931).

Earlier sources (3)

This poem as JSON or plain text. Line anchors #L1–#L16.

Cite this poem

James McIntyre (1828?–1906). “Things Should Be Judged by Merit.” First published in Poems of James McIntyre (1889). Text: Poem Index, https://poemindex.org/james-mcintyre/things-should-be-judged-by-merit/. Append #L14 to cite line 14, or #L4-L9 for lines 4–9.

More by James McIntyre